Neighbor disputes in criminal cases are often the most difficult to resolve. Mr. Corletta was confronted with such a case in People v. WE (Roch. City Ct., 11/20).

In that case, there was continual bad blood, between the client's family and a neighboring family, over a period of years. However, the problem was primarily between relatives of the client and the alleged victim. As with many neighbor disputes, Mr. Corletta's client and the alleged victim got dragged into the dispute.

There were alleged threats made against the client’s family. The client allegedly retaliated by pointing a BB Gun at the alleged victim, resulting in the police being called. The client was subsequently arrested and an Order of Protection issued.

After getting all the facts and then instructing all family members to stay out of it, Mr. Corletta filed the appropriate Motions. There were several heated Court appearances where both families; creating a “Hatfield and McCoys” situation. The Motions resulted in suppression of the alleged gun and any statements Mr. Corletta’s client allegedly made to police, considerably weakening the People's case, and defusing the situation.

As a result, Mr. Corletta was able to obtain an ACD from the People, meaning if his client stays out of trouble for 6 months and participates in a Court-Ordered Mediation Program with the alleged victim; the charge will be dismissed outright. Everyone seemed ready to participate, once the material evidence was suppressed.

Mr. Corletta’s client has government employment and would have lost their job if convicted. Needless to say, the client was extremely grateful for Mr. Corletta's hard work and advocacy and will avoid any and all contact and further problems with the neighbor in the future.