Rochester, New York
16 W Main Street, Suite 204
Rochester, NY 14614
(585) 546-5072
With 34 years of legal victories under his belt and countless satisfied clients behind him, Thomas A. Corletta, Attorney & Counselor at Law comes highly recommended.

Case Review: People v. B.J. (Town Ct., 9/20). September 11, 2020

Rochester, Monroe
Case Review: People v. B.J. (Town Ct., 9/20)., Rochester, New York

MR. CORLETTA OBTAINS RARE ACD IN ANIMAL CRUELTY CASE IN RURAL COUNTY

Animal cruelty cases, usually involving dogs, are treated the same way as human assault cases in rural counties. Defendants are often vilified and PETA gets involved. This makes the disposition Mr. Corletta obtained even more remarkable in People v. B.J. (Town Ct., 9/20).
 

          In a rural county known for tough prosecution of animal cruelty cases, often with involvement from PETA and the community, Mr. Corletta obtained a remarkable disposition, a Conditional Dismissal.

          Here, the dog was found in poor condition in a house that was subsequently condemned and torn down for being filthy. However, there was insufficient proof the dog had not been properly fed or nourished, and there were several other animals in the house. After the dog was taken by the Humane Society, it was quickly restored to good health. It was simply living in filthy conditions. This did not rise to the level of Animal Cruelty under the applicable statute.

          The dog was essentially cleaned up by the Humane Society and adopted out. Mr. Corletta, analyzing the facts, and parlaying the insufficiency of the proof with the fact the dog was easily restored to good health, made a Motion to Dismiss. Rather than oppose the motion and engage in lengthy litigation, the District Attorney agreed to an ACD, agreeing to a dismissal of the case if Mr. Corletta’s client, who had no prior criminal record, was not involved in any further problems over a 6-month period. The record was sealed, and the client suffered no disability.

          This is a remarkable disposition in a county where people often go to jail for these charges. The case is a good example of advocacy, notwithstanding what one’s personal views might be about a matter. The practice of law is about dispassionately analyzing the facts and law and doing the best possible job for the client.

Other Announcements, Events and Deals from Thomas A. Corletta, Attorney at Law
Case Review: People v. BB (Greece Tn. Ct., 10/20)., Rochester, New York
MR. CORLETTA OBTAINS AN OUTRIGHT DISMISSAL OF CHARGE IN ACCIDENT CASE. Using an argument he had used before, based upon his knowledge of the law, Mr. Corletta obtained an outright d...read more
Case Review: People v. WM (Roch. City Ct., 10/20) , Rochester, New York
MR. CORLETTA GETS ANOTHER REDUCTION DESPITE PRIORS, ACCIDENT, & BAD FACTS   In some cases, one must simply persevere. In People v. WM (Roch. City Ct., 10/20), Mr. Corletta...read more
What to Expect After a DWI Arrest in New York, Rochester, New York
Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) is probably the most serious traffic offense you can be arrested for. It is a crime, not a traffic violation, and can result in a criminal record. It ...read more
Case Review: People v. B.C. (DMV-9/20), Rochester, New York
MR. CORLETTA WINS ANOTHER REFUSAL HEARING In a case where his client received 12 charges, including DWI, Obstruction of Governmental Administration, Fleeing Police, and Refusal to t...read more
Case Review: People v. B.C., Rochester, New York
MR. CORLETTA ACHIEVES DISMISSAL OF OBSTRUCTION CHARGE IN POLICE CHASE CASE Police, on a drug and weapons interdiction detail, attempted to stop Mr. Corletta’s client for a purported...read more