Patchogue, New York
75 East Main St.
Patchogue, NY 11772
(631) 475-3663

What Exactly Is an Authentic Italian Pizza? December 11, 2018

Patchogue, Brookhaven
What Exactly Is an Authentic Italian Pizza?, Brookhaven, New York

Many restaurants boast “authentic Italian pizza,” but for the most part, the meaning of this phrase has been lost. Pizza originally hails from Italy. Ever since the United States adopted this dish into its culture, big changes have been made throughout the years. Consequently, most diners aren’t aware of the differences between the U.S. and authentic pizza from Italy. Here are some of the key distinctions to note between the two.

What Are the Differences Between American & Italian Pizza?

1. Thinner Crust

Contrary to popular belief, authentic pizza crust is nothing like the thick, deep-dish Chicago style pie. Italian pizza dough is stretched thin and seasoned before baking. The result is a crispy, light, and flavorful crust. In the United States, you can find a bit more diversity in crusts, from crunchy New York style to the rectangular, thick Sicilian slice.

2. Fresh Sauce

Pizza enthusiasts in the U.S. are accustomed to warm, zesty tomato sauce on their pies. It may come as a surprise that Italians prefer their sauce chilled. You’ll find fresh peeled tomatoes, olive oil, oregano, and garlic on authentic pizza. This gives Italian pizza an herb-infused, garden fresh taste.

3. Bulk Toppings

authentic pizza Most toppings in the United States are diced into neat, easily chewable portions to make bites a little less messy. Italians, on the other hand, go big and bold with their toppings. According to tradition, you may see hefty slices of mozzarella, full basil leaves, and generous discs of prosciutto. Another significant difference is a lack of meat lover’s pizza. Authentic Italian pizza steers clear of mixing meats.

4. Etiquette

Often, you won’t find authentic pizza pre-sliced in Italy like you would in the United States. Thus, it is common courtesy to use a fork and knife, then eat your pieces by hand. Although most Americans tend to pick up pizza slices by hand, it’s not unusual to see diners using utensils on particularly hot pies.

5. Choice

Due to the sheer size of the United States, it’s easy to imagine how pizzas styles and types split off so drastically. While many Italian regions have their own spin on the original, they tend to stick with certain rules and customs. Here, there are no limits to what a pizza restaurant can do to stand out. From fresh Margherita to savory BBQ, you have endless options.


Can’t choose between the U.S. and authentic Italian pizza? Get the best of both worlds at Delfiore Pizza & Food Co. Located on the South Shore of Long Island, this fast and casual pizza place serves a diverse selection of salty, sweet, and savory pies. Order the authentic pizza experience with their Old World special, or choose from over 15 specialty pies. You won’t find their deliciously unique blend of flavors anywhere else. To make a carryout order, visit their website or call (631) 475-3663.

Other Announcements, Events and Deals from Delfiore Pizza & Food Co.
How to Perfectly Reheat Your Pizza at Home, Brookhaven, New York
There’s nothing like enjoying pizza at a restaurant, but the leftovers can be nearly as delicious if you know how to prepare them properly. Instead of settling for cold pizza or more
3 Ways to Enjoy Leftover Pizza, Brookhaven, New York
Carefully crafted from handmade dough, cured meats, and fresh vegetables, a great pizza is a meal that should be savored, which is why many people love leftover pizza. While more
4 Pizza & Wine Pairing Tips , Brookhaven, New York
Whether it’s for date night or a girl’s night in, nothing beats the delectable and comforting combination of pizza and wine. If you’re a wine enthusiast, you probably know white more
The Do's & Don'ts of Food Catering, Brookhaven, New York
Food catering is an excellent choice for everything from weddings and anniversaries to birthdays, reunions, and corporate events. But hosts and event planners more
How to Enjoy Pizza Without the Guilt , Brookhaven, New York
Eating pizza is one of life’s greatest pleasures. If you ordered from your favorite Italian restaurant every night, though, it would probably start showing in your waistline. more