Broadway, Minnesota
5718 International Pkwy
Minneapolis, MN 55428
(612) 217-7759

Should I Repair or Replace My Water Heater? March 13, 2018

Broadway, Crystal
Should I Repair or Replace My Water Heater?, Crystal, Minnesota

If your water heater isn’t working right, you may be wondering if a replacement is in order. In some cases, the answer is obvious, especially if the new installation is cheaper than water heater repairs. You may need some help deciding when it’s not quite so clear-cut.

3 Factors to Consider When Deciding Between Water Heater Repair & Replacement

1. What Is the Problem?

While cost can be an issue for water heater repairs, you need to know what the problem is. If the tank is leaking or corroded, repairs aren’t possible. On the other hand, if it’s a matter of replacing a pressure-relief valve, repairing the water heater is a sensible option. However, if the necessary repairs are costly, opt for a replacement. As a guideline, don’t spend more than half the cost of a new water heater on repairs for the old one.

2. How Old Is Your Water Heater?

water heater repairEven if the repair costs are low, you may decide to have a new water heater installed anyway if yours is nearing the end of its useful life. Water heaters can last between 10 and 15 years or even more than 20 if they’re tankless. If you’re not sure about the age of yours, locate the serial number on the adhesive sticker and check it on the manufacturer’s website.

3. Have You Had Problems Before?

Every appliance will need repairs at some point. That’s not usually a reason to look for a replacement right away. However, if this isn’t the first time you’ve called for water heater repairs or you’ve already dealt with a lack of hot water and high water heating bills, you may save in the long run with a better appliance.


It doesn’t hurt to get an estimate for water heater repairs, especially if it’s a minor problem. The experts at Benjamin Franklin Plumbing in Minneapolis, MN, will perform a thorough inspection and offer their professional recommendation for your situation. They have served the Twin Cities for over 44 years with a variety of plumbing services, including drain cleaning and water heater installation. Visit the website or call (952) 931-9676 to schedule an appointment.

Other Announcements, Events and Deals from Benjamin Franklin Plumbing
Keep Your Basement Dry & Save $150 on a Sump-Pump, Crystal, Minnesota
With spring on the way, the snow is soon to melt and be absorbed into the thawing ground. Don’t let it come up in your basement and flood your home. Many Minnesotan homeowners more
When Should You Replace a Pipe in Your Sewer System?, Crystal, Minnesota
Replacing a pipe in your sewer system might sound like a major headache, but it can be fairly simple. As long as you recognize there’s a problem early on and more
5 Plumbing Services That Will Make Your Valentine’s Day, Crystal, Minnesota
Give your sweetheart the gift of a quality plumbing system this Valentine’s Day. While it may not seem like the most romantic idea in the world, having a system that functions more
Why You Should Switch to a Tankless Water Heater in the New Year, Crystal, Minnesota
It’s that time of year when many are setting goals and resolutions for the months ahead. If your resolution is to improve your home, you might consider installing a more
Why Hydrojetting Is the Answer to Your Clogged Drains, Crystal, Minnesota
Clogged drains can be incredibly frustrating, especially if the problem recurs frequently. While snakes, plungers, and chemical de-cloggers will get the water moving temporarily, more